Comprehensive Analysis: loh-website & loh-wiki

Date: 2026-01-20 Scope: Missing features, bugs, unimplemented behaviors, and content opportunities

Executive Summary

1. Checkout is non-functional (placeholder only)
2. Wiki content is incomplete (many placeholder pages)
3. Download page is non-functional (no actual downloads)
4. Knowledge Base → Wiki sync is partial (55 quests in KB, ~0 on wiki)
5. Several API integrations are mocked
6. Missing user account features (orders, dashboard)

🔴 Critical Issues (Must Fix)

1. Checkout Page is Broken

export default function CheckoutPage() {
    return (
        <div>
            <h1>Checkout</h1>
            <p>The Grand Market is currently closed for maintenance.</p>
        </div>
    );
}

• Implement cart review UI
• Add payment method selection (placeholder until payments integrated)
• Add order summary component
• Connect to the orders table mentioned in pending_tasks.md

2. Download Page Has No Actual Downloads

• Windows button has no href or onClick
• macOS is disabled (Coming Soon)
• No Linux option despite FAQ mentioning Linux support

• Add actual download links when builds are available
• Add "Coming Soon" waitlist for all platforms
• Add version history/changelog section
• Consider adding a Web Client launcher option

3. Wiki Content Gaps vs Knowledge Base

4. Reserve Spot / Email Capture is Mock

// TODO: Connect to actual backend service

🟡 Missing Features (Website)

5. Membership Tab is Commented Out

{/* <TabButton
    label="Membership"
    isActive={activeTab === 'membership'}
    onClick={() => setActiveTab('membership')}
/> */}

6. News Page Has No Dynamic Content Source

• No CMS or database backend
• Content is likely hardcoded or mock data
• No admin interface to publish news

• Integrate with a headless CMS (Sanity, Strapi) or
• Create markdown-based news system in knowledge-base
• Add news article individual pages (/news/[slug])

7. Highscores Page Has Mock Data

8. Support Ticket System is Mock

const handleSubmit = async (e: React.FormEvent) => {
    // Mock API call
    await new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, 1500));
    setSubmitted(true);
};

9. Auth System TODOs

• Line 52: // TODO: Pass captchaToken to API once supported
• Line 96: // TODO: Pass captchaToken to API once supported

10. Mobile App Waitlist is Mock

const handleSubmit = (e: React.FormEvent) => {
    e.preventDefault();
    setSubmitted(true);
    // Mock submission
};

🟡 Missing Features (Wiki)

11. Search Relies on Static JSON Index

• No real-time search
• Index must be manually regenerated
• May become stale

• Implement API endpoint for search
• Add build-time index generation script
• Consider Algolia or Typesense for better search UX

12. No Wiki Edit Functionality

• No edit UI for content
• No version history UI (though wiki_revisions table exists)
• No user contribution system

• Add staff-only edit mode
• Add "Report Issue" button on each page
• Consider adding history viewer

13. Grand Bazaar / Price Checker is Stub

• loh-wiki/src/lib/api/grand-bazaar.ts
• loh-wiki/src/components/grand-bazaar/PriceChart.tsx

• No actual price data
• No trading volume tracking
• No historical charts

14. MTX Price Display Missing Data Source

🔵 Content Expansion Opportunities

15. Quest Content (Priority: HIGH)

• The River's Vow
• Education of Princes
• Division of the Kingdom
• Karna's Companion
• Krishna's Divine Mystery
• Kurukshetra Parts 1-4
• And 46 more...

16. Lore Pages (Priority: HIGH)

• Location lore
• Character backgrounds
• World history
• Faction information

17. Item Database (Priority: MEDIUM)

• Equipment browser (weapons, armor)
• Consumables list
• Material/resource catalog
• Drop table viewer
• GE price history

18. NPC Database (Priority: MEDIUM)

• Monster bestiary with stats
• Shop NPCs and inventories
• Quest NPC locations
• Boss guides

19. Interactive World Map (Priority: MEDIUM)

"An interactive world map will be added after launch."

• Create interactive Leaflet/MapLibre map
• Add location markers (cities, dungeons, resources)
• Add layer toggles (skill locations, transportation)

20. Skill Training Calculators (Priority: MEDIUM)

• XP Calculator (current → target level)
• Optimal training paths per level range
• Cost/profit calculators for production skills
• Time-to-level estimator

21. Money Making Guide Expansion

• Methods table with GP/hour estimates
• Skill requirements breakdown
• Risk levels (PvP areas etc.)
• Quick reference for different tiers (low, mid, high level)

22. Combat Calculators

• Max hit calculator
• DPS calculator
• Equipment comparison tool
• Prayer drain calculator

23. Drop Table Viewer

• Visual drop table display per monster
• Rare drop highlight
• Luck modifier explanations

24. Achievement/Diary System

• Achievement diary pages
• Completion checklists
• Reward displays

🟢 UX/Polish Improvements

25. Community Page Stats are Hardcoded

<div className="text-4xl font-bold">15k+</div>
<div>Discord Members</div>
// All stats are hardcoded mock values

26. Footer Links May Be Broken

27. Missing 404 Handler on Website

28. No Accessibility Review

• Missing aria-labels on some interactive elements
• Color contrast may need review
• Keyboard navigation untested

29. SEO Metadata Incomplete

• Individual news articles need meta tags
• Store items need structured data (JSON-LD)
• Wiki pages need Open Graph images

📋 Prioritized Action Items

Tier 1 (Critical - Before Launch)

1. Implement checkout flow (even with mock payments)
2. Sync 55 quests from KB to Wiki
3. Fix support ticket submission to actually save
4. Add download links or proper "coming soon" modal

Tier 2 (High Priority)

5. Populate wiki with all KB skill content
6. Add lore pages to wiki
7. Implement news CMS or markdown system
8. Create item database browser

Tier 3 (Medium Priority)

9. Interactive world map
10. Skill calculators
11. Combat calculators
12. Drop table viewer
13. Grand Bazaar price tracker

Tier 4 (Polish)

14. Real Discord stats fetch
15. 404 page for main website
16. Accessibility audit
17. SEO structured data

Technical Debt Summary

Conclusion

1. Fix checkout to allow actual purchases (even if payment is mocked)
2. Sync KB → Wiki to expose the 55+ quests and comprehensive skill guides
3. Add interactive tools (calculators, maps) that players expect from a game wiki